Judging the BOTY Awards

Or as I affectionately call them, the booty awards. (Technically, the Book of the Year Awards.)

Since I put my name on the judging sheets and since I suspect I judged them harder than others did, I thought I’d write a note here about my philosophy on judging them.

To me, it’s like judging the Olympics rather than the five-year-old competition or judging for the spot in the symphony rather than high school State orchestra. It’s judging the books as published books, not against anyone who’s ever typed a phrase.

Which means if 3 (out of five) is average, 3 is on par with all published books. Which means I gave mostly 3s. 5s, to me, are perfect 10s (though sadly we’ll never see that again in Olympic gymnastics, not that I’m bitter). 5s are Pulitzer quality.

Also, I judged as a reader, not a writer. In other words, I in no way meant to imply by not giving a 5 that I assume I could do better. Quite the contrary! These books have been published for a reason, and my judging is not a statement on what should be published and what shouldn’t be but how it stands as a published book.

One last note. I’ll probably get in trouble somewhere for saying this, but c’est la vie. Karen Harter, author of Autumn Blue, passed away about a month ago. This may sound selfish, but I’m sad she’ll never see my comments because this was my favorite book of those I judged. I told her I’m now a Karen Harter fan. I told her I want to gather all her books and read them through and through. So I’m saying that here. I’m telling you to read Autumn Blue, and though I haven’t read Where Mercy Flows yet, I suspect it’s good as well.

So there you have it.

That's My Name!

The Genesis award was announced last. And my category was second-to-last. Which means I didn’t eat much of the steak dinner or cheesecake dessert.

About halfway through, maybe somewhere along the BOTY awards, I thought of the perfect thank-you line. I wanted to win so I could use that line.

Nononononono! I jinxed myself by thinking of that line. Go away, line. Get out of my head.

Finally, finally, when I thought my stomach had been reconstructed into a jungle gym for five-year-olds, they got to the Contemporary Women’s Fiction award.

They announced third place. Not me. Then second place. Not me.

(Side note: attending an award’s ceremony when you’re a finalist [or
nominee] is great cardio work-out. My heart out-paced and out-pounded Tchaikovsky’s 1812 Overture.)

Not hearing my name in third or second place must’ve meant I didn’t place. Third place, I thought, was possible. Even less did I think second place. So when they said my name for first place, I convinced myself I misunderstood. I’d heard my own name out of desire. Gina turned to me and said, "You won!"

Then I believed it.

I shimmied to the front, climbed the stage, and delivered my perfect line:

"I’d like to thank the voices in my head and my imaginary friends." Come one, it’s a perfect line for a writer’s conference, isn’t it? Give me some props. "And especially my husband, who besides being the sexiest man in the world, told me I should do this."

Then I walked off. First the wrong direction. They had to point me in the correct direction.

So I’m a Genesis winner. For five minutes I was a celebrity. Of course, the next morning at breakfast, I was invinsible again.

What else from ACFW?

I met Gina (pronounced Jenna) Hernandez. This girl is smart, funny and sassy. We talked writing, books, theology, life for hours on end. I found someone I could be catty with.

Not that I’m catty. No. Never.

I got to know D’Ann Mateer better. This woman is smart, encouraging and amazing. (I met a lot of smart people.)

Gina, D’Ann, and I should have a theme song: "Good morning, good morning. We’ve talked the whole night through. Good morning, good morning to you." Time? That became meaningless in our conversation.

(Do not judge us by this picture. It was the last morning of the conference. We probably had a combined eight hours of sleep. When I say combined, I mean adding together all nights for all of us.)

Friday night, after we sat in Friday’s for oh, seven hours, we thought it might be time to leave. We’d been sitting next to large windows that faced their veranda. As we walked out, some guy who apparently had been on the veranda asked us not to go. They’d been window watching, no, window shopping.

Ah, yes.

I also met J. Mark Bertrand, who is not nearly as scary as I thought he’d be. We conversed about postmodernism, philosophy, and, of course, writing. A lot about writing. The man is incredibly well-read and well-thought about what he’s well-read.

So that was the conference.



Up, Up, and Away

This time tomorrow, I’ll be halfway to Minneapolis,

I saw halfway because my plane leaves at the ungodly hour of 7:30. A.M. In the morning.

As I told my Twitterees, when I’m queen of the world, I’m outlawing mornings.

I had these brilliant things to say to you about writing. I had a carnival (or party) to announce–I’m really excited about it! But I’ll leave those things for next week. (As well as thoughts on the ACFW conference and judging the BOTY contest, which I affectionately dubbed the booty conteset.)

Today I have to pack, take my car in to the shop, and think about my pitch (the 30-second spiel to agents and editors, not the dark, sticky stuff nor how to strike out a batter).

I’d hoped to enjoy some fall weather up north, but it looks like it’ll be in the upper 70s. Gorgeous, to be sure, but not exactly fall.

(Someday can I please move back to Jersey? Pretty please?)

So I leave you now with this fun video:

Don’t you love her imagination?